Thank you... Great reply and ideas.
My other option is to just keep my F350. It's a known entity just bigger than we need and 14MPG.
I will test drive as soon as possible.
Also plan on reading the forums posts on here. I know it's horrific to read all the issue but that is how it is. My new 4Runner has the same on the forums but mine has been flawless so far.
Glad you liked the ride!
I'd second what CMAR said. These trucks are decently quiet on the road, even with more "off-road" tires that I use. They ride well on- and off-road, though on mine I replaced the suspension with Halo Lifts/Elka IFP 2.5 coilover front and rear (all of this is detailed on my build page), though Bilstein and other brands work very well as well, possibly better. And just FYI from Halo Lifts, the basic 2.5s aren't made/acceptable any more for the rear (you can get 2.0, 2.5 with reservoir and 2.5 with reservoir and dampeners). The new suspension did seem to improve the attachment to rougher roads/off-road, but I haven't taken if off-road a lot yet.
I'm also on the V8 bandwagon, for its reliability, though I know the V6 owners are generally very happy with the V6, I know it has more torque, possibly better towing and all that but I don't want to mess with the turbos... when I have enough money for turbos, I'll supercharge the V8. The V8s aren't immune to problems, but they just seem more reliable from what I've seen. I'm currently looking for a used 2023 Tremor and I don't see a lot of V8s for sale- just the V6's and that tells me something.
It's a really good truck- no squeaks on mine that I didn't cause (split loom rubbing against the window...). Safety features seem good. Well-rated in its class. I also drive fairly conservatively, but have noticed on mine that my MPGs are usually somewhat lower, even with the stock tires back on, more around 14 MPG. I have been up to 21 MPG while overloaded in the mountain expressways of West Virginia, and somehow got better MPG while towing a trailer than without, but anyway...
I don't think you can go wrong with a Tremor. While there are changes to the 2024+ models that some people don't like, it's still a good truck. I miss mine and can't wait to get another one.