I agree with you 100%. I think my 24 Tremor V-6 sounds as good or maybe even better than the V-8 , But that’s me. To each his own.
I couldn't disagree more. At best the 3.5L sounds good for a V6. The V8 sounds so much better in my opinion. There really is no comparison. I don't think anything with fewer than 8 cylinders sounds remotely appealing. To me, the V6's sound have a sound somewhere between Fran Drescher singing and a box of sheet metal screws banging around inside a washing machine while trying to herd screaming cats. Compared to a V8, every V6 I've ever heard sound like ass. Truth be told the 5.0L Coyote is far from my favorite sounding V8 either. I prefer larger displacement V8's to the sound of the 5.0L.
It's likely because of the era I grew up in the late 1970's throughout the 1980's. Muscle cars, trucks etc. all had that V8 sound and the surviving cars from the 1960's that were still around
(in fair abundance) had great sounding, larger displacement V8's which sound
"right" to me. Big block engines sound better than small blocks. Higher revving engines, lower displacement engines, and turbocharged 4 and 6 cylinder engines sound somewhere between "OK" and pissed off lawn equipment to me.
To me, putting an exhaust on a V8 sounds great. On most 4 and 6 cylinder engines, I want it to shut the fuck up and do its job. It's better to be seen and not heard.
I love those videos of all these 22 year old Ford tech's who make $16/ hr (with all due respect to them) saying how much they love the V8, but when pressed, it's because "it can make more power". Okay buddy.
I've spent 100's of thousands of miles behind the wheel of F150s. V6's and V8's. I'm going V6 every single time.
If you want to get technical, I think the V8 does have
potential to make more power than the 3.5L EcoBoost generally does. However, that potential is extremely costly to realize, regardless of the methods chosen to get there. Heads, cams and tune will cost thousands. Superchargers cost thousands. Bolt ons, while they may provide some improvement won't really effectively make the 5.0L match the 3.5L EcoBoost in its stock form. Also, swapping cams, heads and things like that on the Coyote sucks. It's a very complex engine and not a lot of fun to work on.
Not to mention, the 3.5L EcoBoost with a tune is a monster in itself and this can be done cheaply. The 3.5L EcoBoost is the way to go if you want the most power out of these trucks off the showroom floor
(Raptor-R not withstanding). Bang for buck, the 3.5L is still the leader for making power cheaply and efficiently.
I agree on the 5.0. I've had the older 3.5 eco w/ the 6 speed. The 5.0 with the 10 speed. The Powerboost hybrid, and now my Tremor is a 3.5. I had zero interest getting back in the 5.0. It's not a bad motor, but when you drive it back to back with the EcoBoost, it feels like an absolute dog. Okay, sure you can supercharge it, but who's really spending $7-$10k doing that? If I ever need more power I'll tune my 3.5 eco.
For me its not about
"need" for more power. I certainly want more power. I'd like to supercharge my 5.0L, and that's the plan. Whether or not I do it is another matter entirely. I have a lot of other things going on so we'll see. Also, you'd be surprised how many people add superchargers to these trucks and the 5.0L Mustangs. I know at least one forum member here has added a supercharger to their TREMOR.
700 plus horsepower out of a 5.0L V8 sounds a shit tone better and makes far more power than a tuned 3.5L EcoBoost ever would. Of course, you can upgrade turbos and do all the other things to make power on the 3.5L EcoBoost as well, but cost wise your probably not that far off of the cost of just adding a supercharger to the 5.0L.
In my opinion........
As far as I am concerned. The 3.5L engine is the way to go for
most people. It will be more fun to drive in stock form. It makes more power and torque than the 5.0L does. It will pull a trailer better, especially at altitude. If you aren't the kind of person to modify your engine, its the best option. If you want even more power with a simple and relatively cheap tune, the 3.5L has the 5.0L beat all the way.
However, if your an old fashioned bastard like me. The 5.0L sound has a nostalgic value all its own. Additionally, if you want to go with a maximum effort build, you'll probably be far better served by the 5.0L in the long run. Unfortunately, you'll have to pay to play in that arena. Modding the 5.0L Coyote engines isn't cheap by any stretch of the imagination.